I still dont understand where problem is, only example i could think of, were to be discussion of characters in complete vacuum, with no feats or hype where its impossible to come to any conclusion because we dont know that they are capable off.... lol
The conclusion is incorrect, obviously.
But one who uses ABC logic and believes in it could use that reasoning. I am trying to show why using ABC logic is terrible
Go see one piece forums they discuss characters in abc fashion all the time and all they have is few words from author