Discussion in 'Naruto Battledome' started by Mouten, Oct 11, 2006.
Who would win?
I've always assumed that Asuma was better than Kisame. It'd be close, but Asuma is on par with Gai and Kakashi, and either of them I think could beat Kisame, so I'll say Asuma still. With him being able to extend his chakra blades at will, he's got an advantage over most swordsmen as they can't judge his striking distance.
Also, keep in mind he totally owned like nine chuunins without putting forth any effort. That's something that normal jounins can't do. He is the elite of the elite.
Gai had a freaking hard time with kisame at only 30% of his chakra, and wether his students were a burden or not is discussable >_< also it seems there is still quite the gap between kakashi and asuma, and that gap is much more narrow when comparing kakashi with gai.
I know its not always as simple as using the "dbz" logic, but damn, we have also seen that encounter with itachi and kisame and it didnt look like they were going to live through it if kakashi wasnt there to counter kisame's suiton jutsu.
Anyway this is just an opinion, and actually my opinion about asuma has improved a lot lately, with the bounty on his head and his performance against hidan. I guess its not impossible for him to win, but frankly it seemed to me that kisame was a greater threat than hidan.
Kisame would not be paired with itachi if he was just big words.
While asuma blade can extend, it is still chakra which extends. Kisame's blade eatch chakra. So the first contact of those two, asuma doesn't have a blade anymore.
Kisame > Gai > Asuma.
kiisame wins this.
Full powered Kisame??!?! with the Samaheda??!!? isn't that a bit too much for Asuma?
Kiasame ftw but even tho he has all that chakra that don't make him > than all. He has more chakra than Itachi and he knows Itachi can beat him.
Kisame wins Asuma but I don't know if he wins easily or not.
Kisame wins,Asuma just isnt like his father was(I mean Saratobi)
Asuma didn't became an elite guard, only because of his chakra blades. I'd go for Asuma.
Asuma. After reading the recent chapters about him, he seems to be good.
So Asuma FTW
Kisame didn't become an Akatsuki member only because of his Samehada.
I voted for Kisame. From fights we've seen Kisame seems stronger (greater strength, better weapon, larger stamina, better ninjutsu, imo)
Uhh... no. Read the latest manga chapters and you'll see how flawed he is. Kakashi would own Asuma.
Is this a joke? Does getting your ass beat by the lower echelons of the Akatsuki automatically make you strong enough to take on their leading men?
There is no way in hell Asuma would win this fight, considering the fact that in the last fight all he did was put a little scratch on Kisame's cheek USING CHAKRA KNIVES!!!!