Discussion in 'Black Clover' started by Keishin, Feb 13, 2018.
Didn't read/watch Rave Master but I did try getting into FT more than once and simply couldn't whereas I started Black Clover since the first chapter was released and never dropped it. So based on that, it's likely that I would prefer BC considering FT and RM have the same author not to mention other similarities.
Plus, BC is a JUMP manga and RM and FT aren't. This is relevant for me cause I seem to have an affinity for JUMP's editorial line, as most of the shonen manga I read are from JUMP. And some manga that haven't worked for me or not as easily are from other magazines.
Fairy Tail was decent until Tenrou island. It has pretty nice art at the beginning.
RAVE Master the anime of RAVE Master the manga?
Because the RAVE Master anime was annoying as hell and cut off just after setting up a cliffhanger in probably its one single decent episode. So I'm still annoyed with it. But I enjoyed the manga much more than FT. Shuda's first fight with Haru is one of my all-time favourites. Lucia was hyped up as well as the Spriggan 12 were hyped up terribly. And a couple of deaths genuinely hit me in the feels. Even if there were some extremely annoying characters every now and then in the manga. Its special to me as the first manga I read. And the anime dumped on it, particularly by making Elie so whiny for no apparent reason.
Whereas Black Clover was a very faithful adaptation of a hilariously terrible manga. So I don't really mind that. Its just fun to laugh at.
I liked Rave Master's English opening.
Rave Master is a master piece.
It's a shame they dropped the ball and sucked up the anime RIGHT when it hits the turning point where it begins to stand out.
Black Clover is just good.
Nothing spectacularly amazing about it.....
Exactly. Rave Master's a way better than Black Clover,. Easily one of the best Shonen Nekketsu. There're not even on the same Level of greatness.
Seriously rave is like one of the few of any mangas I can go back and reread it numerous times with emotion and enjoyment .
Can’t think of many others I can do that with
Rave Master had nice story and character moments but could get pretty dull at times. Black Clover is a lot of things but never boring.
Haven't read Black Clover yet. Is Asta as generic as Haru? I'll say Rave cuz the second half of the story and the ending is right up there with Yu Yu Hakusho and others for me. Still Haru is one of the dullest blandest MC I've seen since Naruto. His personality is literally just "I like doing what's right! I also hate bad guys they're total dorks"
Rave was the first manga I ever actually read. I remember when the Raws were still being translated and having to read summaries for chapters etc... Its what started my love of manga. So it'll always have a special place in my heart. But it is also the reason I can enjoy series like Nanatsu no Taizai and Black Clover, because they have a sort of feel to them that can at times be reminiscent of Rave.
Haven't read Rave Master yet but BC is faaaar better than fairy fail.
Rave master was awesome